Queer Duck faces a midlife crisis when he meets a Broadway actress named Lola Buzzard, leading to a chaotic rescue mission and a showdown with Reverend Vandergelding, a homophobic bigoted priest who attempts to turn him straight, but ultimately fails. As Queer Duck navigates his relationships with Lola and his partner Openly Gator, he must confront his own identity and the consequences of embracing or rejecting his gayness. With the help of friends like Bi-Polar Bear, Oscar Wildcat, and Rex, Queer Duck learns to accept himself for who he is. In the end, Queer Duck returns to being gay, reuniting with Openly Gator and finding happiness in his true identity.