Lizzie Moore (Lindy Booth) is a young piano teacher working at a music school in Brooklyn. She meets Brad (Robin Dunne), who takes an interest in her playing and asks to hire his teenage daughter Abigail (Micah Kalisch). As Lizzie works with Abigail, sparks fly between her and Brad, but she's shocked to discover he's also interested in the property housing the music school. To save the school and the event, a major Christmas fundraiser, Lizzie must navigate her feelings for Brad while fighting to preserve her beloved institution.