In "Hayride to Hell", Farmer Sam (Bill Moseley) takes drastic action against those who have wronged him, exacting bloody revenge on unscrupulous townsfolk. The film features a range of unsettling imagery, from witch burning and gruesome stunts involving pumpkins and flamethrowers, to a car wreck and the execution of a hanged man. Meanwhile, Sheriff Jubel (Kane Hodder) tries to keep order in the town amidst the chaos.