After Shenaniganz loses its hottest waitresses to new competitor Ta-Ta's Wing Shack, where the scantily clad wait staff earns bigger tips, the Shenaniganz staff aims to give Ta-Ta's its just desserts. Character Dennis (John Michael Higgins) tries to motivate his crew to meet a $9,000 sales goal by threatening to close the restaurant if they don't succeed. Meanwhile, Calvin (Robert Patrick Benedict), manager of next-door bar Ta-Ta's, and new waitress Allison face their fears as they try to attract customers and find self-discovery.