In the sleepy New England town of Loblolly By The Sea, a mysterious blue love letter arrives that ignites renewed interest among its residents, sparking an unexpected quest to uncover its authorship. Determined to find the letter's writer, Helen MacFarquhar embarks on a journey that leads her to two men: George, an old friend from her past, and Johnny, a young man in her present. As she navigates the misunderstandings and miscommunications surrounding the letter, Helen finds herself caught between her feelings for these two men, each thinking they are the author of the love note.